Professional water heater repairing service

Water Heater Repair or Replacement in Harrisburg

Cold water ruining your morning, strange sounds coming from the tank, or rusty stains near the heater can make daily life stressful. When you face hot water issues, you want honest answers and real solutions from people who understand your home. At Handyside Plumbing, HVAC & Electrical, we proudly serve homes and other property owners in Harrisburg, York, and nearby areas.

Our licensed team diagnoses problems with clarity, explains repair or replacement paths in simple words, and restores hot water with skill. Call or fill out our online request form now to schedule a water heater repair or replacement service.

717-752-1177
717-752-1177
Get $50 OFF plumbing service Today!
PLUMBING
$50 OFF
Discount Coupon
duct
heater
ac-outdoor-unit

Unlock $50 in plumbing savings, limited‑time coupon!

*Offers cannot be combined and are not valid on past work.

See Our Specials
Water around the base of heater

Signs You Need Water Heater Repair

Many water heater problems start small and grow over time. If you notice odd shifts in your water heater system, it may be time for a repair. Common warning signs include:

  • Little or no hot water during normal use
  • Water that turns cool too fast
  • Popping or rumbling sounds from the tank
  • Rusty or dirty water from hot taps
  • Water around the base of the heater
  • Sudden jumps in energy bills
Newly installed water heater system

How Our Water Heater Replacement Services Can Assist You

Older water heaters often struggle to maintain temperature, leading to higher energy costs, rust, and potential leaks. Proactively replacing your unit prevents costly water damage and makes sure you aren't left in the cold. Trust Handyside Plumbing, HVAC & Electrical to upgrade your home with a high-efficiency water heater system.

We provide expert water heater replacement services designed to lower your expenses and deliver reliable hot water for years to come. You can also prevent unexpected repair expenses, unexpected cold showers, and potential water damage to walls or floors by planning a replacement before a complete breakdown.

Installed water heater system

When are New Water Heaters More Effective?

A water heater does not last forever. At a certain point, putting more time and money into repairs gives less value than upgrading. A new water heater becomes a smarter choice in situations like these:

  • Energy use climbs
  • Hot water supply drops
  • Frequent breakdowns
  • Visible wear and leaks
Dad's promise guarantee logo

Our Dad’s Promise Guarantee

At Handyside Plumbing, HVAC & Electrical, every job starts with a father’s promise. Bryan Handyside built this company on hard work and pride in doing things the right way. Our team of experts carries that promise into every home. They’re the best in skill, attitude, and workmanship.

We complete the job with precision and efficiency, cleaning up when we’re finished and taking responsibility for your satisfaction. Our Dad’s Promise Guarantee means every repair, installation, or service meets the same standard Bryan expects in his own home.

And if something isn’t right, we make it right, because that’s what Dad does.

Learn More Now!

Types of Water Heaters and When Repairing or Replacing Them Makes Sense

Homeowners use different water heater systems, and each type has unique signs that call for attention. Our team works on all common models and helps you pick the right fit for your lifestyle and daily hot water use.

An installed traditional water heater Traditional Tank Water Heaters

Traditional tanks gather and store hot water for quick use. These units can need repair if you hear popping sounds, see rusty water, or if your heated water is inconsistent. Replacement may be needed for tanks older than 10 years, tanks with corrosion, or tanks with repeated leaks.

An installed tankless water heater Tankless Water Heaters

Heats water on demand with no storage tank. A tankless unit may need repair if you notice long waits for hot water, inconsistent temperatures, or error codes on the display. Replacement may be needed for units with heavy mineral buildup, heat exchanger failure, or age beyond normal life expectancy.

An installed hybrid heat pump system Hybrid Heat Pump Water Heaters

Uses heat pump technology to warm water in a storage tank. Repair may be needed if the unit stops heating during cold months, makes loud noises, or shows sensor issues. Replacement may be needed when the system struggles to keep up with demand, needs frequent parts, or reaches the end of its life.

Collage of dishwasher, installed faucet, and installing showerhead

More Of Our Plumbing Services

Water heater service is one part of keeping a home in good shape. Our licensed plumbers also help with many other needs around the house. We fix problems, replace worn parts, and install new fixtures with care. Our plumbing services include:

Call Us Now to Restore Your Water Heater Performance in York

Don’t let a failing water heater disrupt your home. Our certified team provides expert repair and replacement services, helping you choose and install an energy-efficient water heater system that fits your household needs. We also offer water sensors for early leak detection to help you avoid costly damage or electrical hazards.

From quick repairs to full system upgrades, we deliver reliable solutions that keep hot water flowing without interruption. Call or contact us online today, and let our experts help assess your water heater repair or replacement needs and services.

717-752-1177

Water Heater Repair or Replacement Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How often should Handyside Plumbing, HVAC & Electrical service my tankless water heater?
A tankless water heater should get serviced once a year to keep it clean and efficient. Hard water can cause scale inside the system, so some homes need two service visits each year. Regular service helps the unit last longer and keeps performance steady.
When is new water heater replacement a smarter choice than repair?
A new unit can save money when the old one is past ten years, needs repairs often, or has leaks in the tank. Older models also use more energy, so utility bills stay high. Modern units, especially tankless ones, cost less to run and can give long-term value.
How long does water heater installation by Handyside Plumbing, HVAC & Electrical take?
Most standard tank replacements take a short time. Tankless systems or plumbing changes take longer. Our team works fast and keeps disruption low while doing clean and safe work.
Do your tankless water heaters last longer than tank models?
Most of the time, yes. Tank units last about eight to twelve years. Tankless units can last twenty years or more with good care. Long life plus better efficiency makes tankless a popular pick for homeowners.

Our Authorized Plumbing Brands

Preferred Brands:

Additional Brands:

Recently Completed Jobs

See All

Mechanicsburg, PA

After evaluating the home’s plumbing system and hot water usage, we recommended a water heater replacement along with a new water softener system to improve performance, efficiency, and water quality. Our team safely shut off the water supply, dra...

Our customers love us!

See All

4.97 out of 485 reviews

Other pages you may be interested in...

Hot water plays a crucial role in everyday life. Showers, laundry, dishwashing—every task depends on a reliable and efficient system.

What
Our Customers
Are Saying About Us
We had a great experience with Handyside, and more importantly our service tech - John McLean was the best.
I decided to go with Handyside after reaching out to my normal HVAC company and not getting a response back. I am 10,000% happy!
This was the best service appointment we’ve had with any company in some time.
KK
 
Had an excellent experience getting electrical issues addressed in my kitchen.

Ask for a Quote Today!

We focus on giving every customer an exceptional experience by prioritizing reliable and transparent service. Reach out today to schedule your appointment.

717-752-1177

Handy Advantage Partner Plan (HAPPM)

Save more and stress less with our Handy Advantage Partner Plan membership. Get priority service, exclusive perks, and added value on every visit, year-round protection included.